Blackjack Insurance Explained – A Guide to the Popular Side Bet

Blackjack insurance is one of the most common yet misunderstood side bets in the game. Its real value has always been open to debate. In this guide, we’ll break down what blackjack insurance is, how it works, when it might make sense to use it, and whether it’s worth it, based on statistics, strategy, and probability.

What Is Blackjack Insurance?

Blackjack insurance is a side bet that’s offered to players when the dealer’s upcard is an Ace. It’s essentially a way to protect your main hand against the possibility that the dealer has a natural blackjack.

If you take insurance, you place an additional bet – usually half your original stake, that pays out 2:1, against the dealer’s facedown card being a 10-value (10, J, Q, K). If the dealer does have blackjack, your insurance bet wins. The idea is to soften the blow of losing your main hand.

It might sound smart, but it’s also controversial. Insurance is one of the most misunderstood and debated bets in blackjack – as we will explain.

How Does Insurance Work in Blackjack? 

Blackjack insurance is offered only when the dealer’s face-up card is an Ace. There is a real risk – approximately 31.5% – that they will hit a blackjack – a two-card 21, with an Ace and a 10-value card. If they don’t have blackjack, the insurance bet is lost, and the round continues as usual.

Here’s a step-by-step example: 

1. You bet $10 on your main hand.

2. The dealer shows an Ace.

3. You’re offered insurance and choose to place a $5 insurance bet.

4. If the dealer has a 10, they have blackjack. You lose your main $10 bet but win $10 from insurance (2:1 payout on $5), breaking even overall.

5. If the dealer doesn’t have blackjack, your $5 insurance bet is lost, and you continue playing the round with your original hand.

This option gives the illusion of protection, but in reality, it’s a separate gamble with different odds – and they’re not great, as we will reveal.

Probability & House Edge of Blackjack Insurance

Let’s talk numbers. On paper, blackjack insurance might sound like a helpful safety net. Statistically, it just doesn’t add up.

When the dealer shows an Ace, there are 16 ten-value cards, out of 52, in a standard deck (10, J, Q, K in each of the four suits), giving a roughly 30.8% chance that the dealer has blackjack.

Now consider the payout – insurance pays 2:1, meaning for every $1 you bet, you’ll win $2 if the dealer has blackjack. But since the actual odds are closer to 1 in 3, you’re getting a payout that doesn’t match the risk.

This mismatch results in a house edge of around 7.5% in multi-deck blackjack games. In single-deck games, the edge can climb as high as 8.75%. So, while it might feel like you’re playing it safe, insurance is a high-risk bet dressed up as protection.

Blackjack Insurance Strategy: When to Take It 

Although blackjack insurance is generally not recommended, there are a few particular situations where it makes sense. Here are three reasons why a player might consider taking insurance.

✔️ 1. You’re Counting Cards 

If you’re an advanced player, using a card counting system like Hi-Lo, and you know the deck is rich in 10-value cards, insurance can be a profitable move. For example: You’ve counted a high number of 10s remaining in the deck – the dealer shows an Ace. You take insurance because the probability of the dealer having blackjack is now greater than 33.3%.

✔️ 2. You’re Playing Single-Deck Blackjack

In a single-deck game, you have better information about the remaining cards. Therefore, card counting is more effective. That makes insurance slightly more viable, but only if you’re using a strategy. 

The game uses a single deck. You’ve seen a lot of low cards drawn. You estimate a high chance that the next card is a 10, making insurance slightly more favorable.

✔️ 3. You’re in a Tournament Situation

In rare cases, like blackjack tournaments, insurance might help preserve your position if losing your hand would knock you out of contention.

Let’s say you’re in the final hand of a tournament. You’re ahead by a narrow margin. Taking insurance would lock in a win or keep you in the game even if the dealer has blackjack.

When Not to Take Blackjack Insurance

Most of the time, insurance is a bad bet, particularly for casual players. The odds simply don’t justify the payout. The house edge makes it a long-term drain on your bankroll.

Here are three clear-cut situations when you should skip the insurance option:

❌ 1. You’re Not Counting Cards

Without counting cards, you’re essentially guessing whether the dealer has blackjack. Since the odds are against you, insurance is a sucker’s bet.

Let’s use this example: The dealer shows an Ace. You’re playing for fun and have no clue how many 10s remain. You take insurance, and you lose it 70% of the time. Why bother?

❌ 2. You Have a Strong Hand

Players often want to ‘protect’ a good hand like 20 by taking insurance. But this is a psychological trap – insurance is a separate bet. Your strong hand doesn’t affect the dealer’s odds of blackjack.

If you’re holding a 10 and a Queen (20), and the dealer shows an Ace. You insure your bet, only to lose the insurance because the dealer didn’t have blackjack. Now you’ve thrown away half a bet for no reason.

❌ 3. You’re on a Budget

Insurance eats into your bankroll with no real long-term benefit. If you’re playing conservatively or trying to make your money last, you’re better off declining the bet every time.

If you bet $10 per hand, and insurance asks for $5 more. Over 20 hands, that’s $100 in extra bets that are statistically stacked against you.

Top Tips for Blackjack Insurance

While insurance is rarely the optimal move, it helps to know how to approach it like a pro, especially if you’re tempted to click that button in a live online game. Here are some quick-fire tips to help you handle blackjack insurance wisely.

Know What You’re Betting

Insurance isn’t about your hand – it’s a side bet on whether the dealer has a 10 underneath their Ace. Don’t let a strong hand (like a 20) emotionally trick you into thinking you need to protect it.

Avoid It, Unless You’re Counting Cards

If you’re not using a card counting strategy, the odds are simply not in your favor. The house edge is too high for casual bets.

Don’t Confuse It with ‘Even Money’

When you have blackjack and the dealer shows an Ace, you might be offered ‘even money’. That’s just insurance by another name. And yes, it’s still a bad bet mathematically, unless you’re a card counter.

Stick to Basic Strategy First

Before diving into side bets like insurance, master basic blackjack strategy, which is proven to reduce the house edge on the main game, unlike insurance, which increases your risk.

Is Blackjack Insurance Worth It?

To be honest, in most cases, no. Blackjack insurance is not worth it for the average player. Although it sounds like a smart safety net, the math simply doesn’t back it up.

Whether you’re playing at land-based tables or trying live dealer games at trusted online casinos, insurance is always presented when the dealer shows an Ace.

Statistically, when the dealer shows an Ace, they’ll only have a blackjack around 30% of the time. That means you’re losing your insurance bet nearly 70% of the time.

Given that the payout is only 2:1, the odds don’t reflect the risk. The house edge on insurance bets is steep, about 7.5% in multi-deck games. This makes it one of the least player-friendly options at the table.

What About Player Budgets?

If you’re playing small stakes and looking to stretch your bankroll, insurance is usually a bad call. It adds unnecessary risk and eats away at your balance. Mid-range players might be tempted to protect bigger hands like a 20. However, insurance doesn’t care what you’re holding. It’s purely a bet on the dealer’s hole card.

High rollers or card counters are the only players who might occasionally benefit. If you’re keeping track of the deck and know it’s loaded with 10s, then the odds can swing in your favor. But this is a very advanced strategy.

Bottom line: unless you’re an expert card counter, taking insurance is rarely a good move.

How Blackjack Insurance Could Work

For blackjack insurance to be fair, the payout should match the true odds of the dealer having blackjack – roughly 30.8% of the time. That means instead of the standard 2:1 payout, the bet would need to pay around 2.23:1. This would bring the house edge down to roughly 0.5%.

If it paid 3:1, the player would have a 23% advantage, which is why casinos never offer it. The current 2:1 payout simply doesn’t reflect the real risk. It stacks the odds in the house’s favor.

Blackjack Insurance Outcomes on a $10 Bet

Payout Odds	If the Dealer Has Blackjack	If the Dealer Doesn’t	Net Expected Value	House Edge / Player Edge
2:1 (standard)	Win $20	Lose $10	–$0.76	+7.6% house edge
2.23:1 (fair odds)	Win $22.30	Lose $10	–$0.05	+0.5% house edge
3:1	Win $30	Lose $10	+$2.32	+23.2% player edge

Assumptions:

• Dealer shows an Ace (insurance offered)
• The dealer has blackjack approximately 30.8% of the time
• Expected value is based on: (Win % × Win Amount) – (Loss % × Bet)

Conclusion

Blackjack insurance might sound like a smart way to protect your hand, but – for most players – it’s a costly distraction. Yes: it pays 2:1. Unfortunately, the odds of the dealer having blackjack don’t justify the bet. It gives the house a significant edge.

Unless you’re counting cards or playing in a particular scenario like a single-deck tournament, insurance is best avoided. It doesn’t depend on your hand; it’s not a safeguard, it’s a side bet with poor value over the long run.

Stick to a solid basic strategy, manage your bankroll wisely, play responsibly, and if you’re serious about improving, learn how card counting affects the math behind bets like insurance. Otherwise, your safest bet is to simply say “no, thanks” when the insurance offer pops up.

FAQs